HOP list   Monthly Events

HINODE Operation Plan (HOP)

accepted on

23-feb-2023


 HOP No.

 HOP title

HOP 0456

[SOOP: Major Flare Watch] Search for Evidence of Nonthermal Proton Beams During Major Flare Watch

plan term

2023/04/05-2023/04/05

@ @

proposer

 name : Inglis, Brosius, Kucera, Young, Kerr @  e-mail : andrew.inglis[at]nasa.gov, jeffrey.w.brosius[at]nasa.gov

contact person in HINODE team

 name : Savage, Watanabe, De Pontieu @  e-mail : sabrina.savage[at]nasa.gov, watanabe.tetsuya[at]nao.ac.jp, bdp[at]lmsal.com

 abstract of observational proposal
Main Objective: We seek to obtain EIS and IRIS flare stare spectra within the same active region as that from which SPICE flare stare spectra will be obtained.

Scientific Justification:
Accelerated protons may make up half the energy budget of solar flares, but evidence for their presence is very difficult to observe. The SPICE observations for the upcoming Solar Flare SOOP are focused on detecting accelerated flare protons via the Orrall-Zirker effect (Orrall & Zirker1976). This mechanism posits that flare accelerated protons stream through the solar atmosphere and, through charge exchange, collisional excitation, and radiative de-excitation, produce very red-shifted photons that may be detected in the wings of H Ly and H Ly . Our simulations indicate this highly red-shifted radiation may be detectable with SolO/SPICE observations of solar flare ribbons (Kerr et al. 2023, in preparation). The only previous detection of such emission was reported by Woodgate et al. (1992) based on GHRS observations of a flare on the M dwarf star AU Mic. Our SPICE program is focused on sit-and-stare observations to detect red wing enhancements of Ly without corresponding blue wing enhancements, plus other lines of interest for flare modeling.

We seek to obtain EIS and IRIS flare stare spectra within the same active region as that from which SPICE flare stare spectra will be obtained. Given the uncertainties on the pointings of spectrometer slits (e.g., ~15 arcsec for EIS), the probability of precisely coaligning the three slits of SPICE, EIS, and IRIS in stare mode is negligible. Although raster scans with EIS and IRIS would be useful, we prefer to capitalize on the rapid cadence stare capabilities of these instruments, and rely upon coordinated observations with imagers to provide context images. With this in mind, the slit pointings of SPICE, EIS, and IRIS would be deliberately offset from each other. In this way we can investigate the observed featurefs (ideally a flare ribbon) behavior simultaneously at three different locations. Although the EIS and IRIS stare spectra will not provide direct evidence of nonthermal proton beams, they will each provide the time evolution of the flaring solar atmosphere over nearly three orders of magnitude in temperature at their respective pointing positions. This will tell us, at both pointing positions, the onset time of a flare, whether chromospheric evaporation proceeds explosively or gently based on line-of-sight Doppler velocities as functions of temperature, and whether nonthermal electrons are accelerated continuously or quasi-periodically (in bursts). Density sensitive line intensity ratios will also be used to determine the time evolution of flare plasma density at the formation temperatures of density sensitive line pairs, at their separate locations. Coordinated, deliberately offset stare spectra have been obtained with EIS and IRIS in the past, and provided valuable diagnostics of the flaring solar atmosphere at the two different locations in a flare ribbon (e.g., Brosius, Daw, & Inglis 2016).

 request to SOT
None

 request to XRT
High cadence obs (~10s) with 384x384 fov, thin-Be, similar to HOP 361.
Please disable FLD if it is safe to do so; otherwise reduce cadence of flare patrol images to 80 sec (use FLD table 0018).
Suggest XOB #1BDC or similar.

 request to EIS
We ask that EIS run the existing flare stare study titled: gRapid_Cadence_EIS_Flare_Stareh (Acronym FLAREDOP_EIS, Study ID 472, Raster ID 449) continuously during the SPICE continuous stare.
This study uses 10 s exposures with an overall cadence around 11.18 s, and acquires spectra in five wavelength bins (262.0 - 265.5 A, 268.0 - 270.0 A, 273.8 - 274.5 A, 275.0 - 277.0 A, and 279.5 - 281.0 A) from the EIS long-wavelength channel, recording them in 1 arcsec pixels along a 184 arcsec segment of the 2 arcsec wide slit.
The study includes lines of Fe XVI at 262.976 A, Fe XXIII at 263.766 A, Fe XIV at 264.789 A, Mg VI at 268.991 A, Fe XIV at 274.204 A, and Si VII at 275.361 A, with lines of O III, Fe XVII and others also being observed. Density-sensitive line pairs of Fe XIV and Mg VII are included.

 other participating instruments
Additional instrument coordination: Solar Orbiter [SOOP: Major Flare Watch]
https://issues.cosmos.esa.int/solarorbiterwiki/display/SOSP/Solar+Orbiter+Planning+-+for+coordination+with+external+parties

Previous HOPs: N/A

 remarks
Dates: Apr 5, 2023

Time window: 09:00 - 17:56 UT during Major Flare Watch SOOP
Refer to coordination page in Additional Instrument Coordination.

Target(s) of interest: Flaring active region

HOP list   Monthly Events